The Game-Changing Clause For Entrepreneur , VC Funds Are Mostly Just Wasting Their Time and Your Money, VC Jobs & More
Clause For Convertible Note | VC's Effectiveness Morgan Stanley's Study | VC Jobs
📢 Today At A Glance
- Game Changing Clause Every Entrepreneur Should Add to Their Convertible Notes - Article: VC Funds Are Mostly Just Wasting Their Time and Your Money
- Interesting Tweet on: Fusion Fuel to to power our current civilization.
- Weekends reading on startups, technology, life and entrepreneurship.
- VC Job: This Week's Top 10 Jobs.
📢 Clause Every Entrepreneur Should Add to Their Convertible Notes
I stumbled upon a fascinating article by a Silicon Hills lawyer called "The Problem in Everyone's Capped Convertible Notes," and it really caught my attention. It delves into an issue that affects entrepreneurs far and wide: the hidden dangers of capped convertible notes. I couldn't resist sharing this valuable insight with all of you. So, let's cut to the chase and explore the essential paragraph that every entrepreneur needs to include in their convertible notes.
Before this - I hope you understand the Convertible note very well, if not please read our previous writeup - Understanding Convertible Note
So, here's the deal. When you get into bed with a convertible note that has a cap and converts into the next funding round, there's a dirty little secret waiting to bite you in the backside. If your venture takes off and you raise funds at a higher price than the cap, those early angels can end up with "multiple liquidation preferences" on their precious dollars. Let me break it down for you:
Let's say an angel invests $500,000 with a $5 million cap. That means they'll own at least 9% of your company if the conversion price exceeds the cap. If you raise funds at a lower price, their ownership goes up (pretty straightforward, right?).
Now, with a regular 1x liquidation preference, they'd be entitled to $500,000 if you sell the company for less than $5 million. If you sell for more, they'd rather take their ownership percentage instead of that liquidation preference, which acts like a safety net.
Fast forward a bit. You work your tail off for 18 months, securing a series of notes, and guess what? You're lucky enough to land $5 million at a juicy $25 million pre-money valuation. At this point, that early angel investor owns around 16.67% and probably still holds a 1x liquidation preference.
Now here's where the trickery starts: When the initial note converts, instead of snagging a $500,000 liquidation preference, they'd cash in a mind-boggling $2.5 million liquidation preference—a whopping 5x increase!
If a venture capitalist pulled this stunt on an early-stage deal, they'd be scorched by such a bad rep that no other VC or entrepreneur would touch them with a ten-foot pole. In VC financings, this stuff is out in the open so entrepreneurs know what they're getting into. But with convertible notes, it's all implicit, and we end up scratching our heads later, wondering how we got shafted. It's the silent screwing that really stings.
But fear not, my friends! I've got a weapon to arm you against this injustice. Here's what you need to add pronto to any convertible note you're raising money on. And mark my words, if an angel refuses to agree to this, it's time to run like the wind and find someone else. Heck, I'd love to see a website that exposes these sneaky angels. I've got some big-name culprits in mind, but I won't start a public feud... yet.
Here's the magic clause to include:
"If this note converts at a price higher than the cap you're given, you agree that when it's converted into equity, your stock will be converted to entitle you to no more than a 1x non-participating liquidation preference, plus any agreed-upon interest."
Papering this when it converts is super easy if the angel has already consented to it and they are not being cheated at all. They get their full investment as a 1x liquidation preference. And please don’t let any angel try to convince you they deserve more for the early risk. The early risk is why they get a cheaper price.
Join 4000+ investors, founders, operators, students, startups & vc enthusiasts to receive such updates on startups, venture capital, technology and VC Jobs.
Now, I'm no lawyer, so it's wise to get some legal advice to make sure this clause is airtight. But trust me, adding this baby will give you some much-needed protection and level the playing field. Don't let any angel sweet-talk you into thinking they deserve more for taking the early risk. Their sweet deal on the price already compensates.
For those seeking a more comprehensive understanding, I highly recommend checking out an exceptional post by José Ancer on the topic of the "liquidation preference overhang."
📢 VC Funds Are Mostly Wasting Their Time and Your Money
The Financial Times recently highlighted a study by Morgan Stanley's equity strategists, Edward Stanley and Matias Øvrum, that challenges the venture capital (VC) industry's claims of delivering superior returns for investors. The study's key findings are:
VC Funds vs. Stocks: Over the past two decades, VC funds have typically failed to consistently outperform stocks. This undermines the industry's assertion of being a profitable investment avenue.
Rare High Returns: While there are instances where investors have enjoyed extraordinary returns by choosing top-performing VC funds, these cases are infrequent and often linked to factors such as early backing of tech giants or benefiting from the 2021 SPAC boom.
Risk and Returns: Despite being riskier than investing in equities, VC investments have not consistently delivered better returns than index funds.
Power Law Distribution: The study highlights that returns in the VC industry follow a power law distribution, where a few winners significantly outperform while many others underperform, emphasizing the challenges of picking successful VC investments.
Valuation Challenges: The study underscores the issue of overvaluation in VC. Companies often use complex equity structures with different classes of shares, making it challenging to determine the true value of equity. This practice can lead to inflated valuations.
Investor Psychology: Despite the data suggesting that VC returns are often lacklustre, there's persistent optimism among some investors who believe they can beat the odds. This psychological bias may contribute to continued interest in VC investments.
In summary, the study by Morgan Stanley provides further evidence that the VC industry's claims of superior returns are often not substantiated by data. Issues such as overvaluation and the complexity of equity structures contribute to this disconnect. You can read the detailed report here - Check it out
📢 Interesting tweet on: Fusion fuel to power our current civilization
Andrew Côté recently shared a detailed tweet on how the ocean contains fusion fuels that can power us for 65 billion years. Worth to read if you are a tech guy!
📢 Weekends Reading On Startups, Technology, Life and VC.
Balancing the Art of Valuation with the Science of Dilution - Read Here
Investment Committee 101: how VCs decide to back a startup - Read Here
5 founders discuss why SAFEs are better for early-stage and bridge rounds - Read Here
What to do about your traction slide when you don’t have revenue yet - Read Here
Understanding how VCs think (The Math behind Venture Capital) - Read Here
📢 Venture Capital Remote | Hybrid Jobs
💼 Future Partner (Principal) - Spacecadet Venture 📍Remote - Apply Here
💼 VC Internship - Spacecadet Venture 📍Remote - Email at: daniel@spacecadet.ventures
💼 Investment Associate - Unique Capital 📍Remote Email at office@uniqaventures.com
💼 VC Partner - Cancer Fund 📍Remote - Apply Here
💼 VC Internship - Muse Capital 📍Remote - Apply Here
For More Jobs, check this out - theventurecrew
📢 Featured: VC Daily Digest
VC Daily Digest: A Daily Dose of Venture Insights, Funding Updates, And Startup Stories, Delivered Straight To Your Inbox.
Join the 2400+ Top executives from leading firms to receive daily updates on Startups Investing, startups, technology, AI and Venture Capital.
🤝 Interested In Sponsoring This Newsletter?: Apply to Partner With Us! Click To get In Touch 🦄 Join Our Startup Partner’s Community Space.
"The Venture Crew" is a globally active community of 2000+ (still counting) funders, founders, operators & VC enthusiasts from leading firms.
✍️Written By The Venture Crew Team